Is a Public Defender Enough? When to Hire a Private Criminal Lawyer in Cleveland

When you’re charged with a crime in Ohio, the decisions you make in the first 24 hours can shape your entire future. One of the most important? Deciding whether to rely on a public defender or hire a private criminal defense lawyer. At Patrick M. Farrell Co. L.P.A., we know this choice can feel overwhelming—especially when your freedom, reputation, and criminal record are at stake. With decades of experience defending clients in Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, and across Northeast Ohio, our legal team is here to guide you through the critical moments that follow an arrest.

What’s the Difference Between a Public Defender and a Private Criminal Lawyer?

Public defenders are court-appointed attorneys who represent individuals who cannot afford to hire legal counsel. While many are hardworking and experienced, they are often burdened by massive caseloads and limited resources.

By contrast, a private criminal defense lawyer—such as those at Patrick M. Farrell Co. L.P.A.—is hired directly by the client. This means:

• You choose your attorney, rather than being assigned one at random
• You receive more personalized attention, with time dedicated to your unique situation
• Your defense strategy is proactive, with early and aggressive advocacy from the moment you're charged

The Reality of Public Defense in Cuyahoga County and Northeast Ohio

In Cuyahoga County, the public defender’s office is tasked with handling thousands of felony and misdemeanor cases annually. While these attorneys are committed professionals, the sheer volume of cases often limits their ability to provide:

• Thorough investigation of facts and evidence
• In-depth strategy development before trial
• Timely and consistent client communication

At Patrick M. Farrell Co. L.P.A., we frequently meet clients who initially relied on public defenders but came to us seeking more dedicated representation after feeling unheard, uninformed, or underprepared.

When Should You Hire a Private Criminal Lawyer in Ohio?

You should consider hiring a private criminal defense attorney when:

1. You’re Facing Serious or Felony Charges

Charges such as aggravated assault, drug trafficking (O.R.C. § 2925), or felony OVI (O.R.C. § 4511.19) carry severe penalties—potentially including years in prison. A private attorney can:

• Craft a custom defense strategy
• Challenge illegal searches or flawed arrests
• Negotiate favorable plea deals with prosecutors who respect our reputation

2. You Need to Protect Your Career or Reputation

If you’re a professional, student, or caregiver in Cleveland, Parma, or Euclid, a criminal conviction could permanently damage your career or future plans. Our legal team understands how to defend your name and minimize public exposure during litigation.

3. You Want More Control Over Your Case

Working with Patrick M. Farrell Co. L.P.A. means you’ll always know:

• Who is handling your defense
• What the legal strategy is
• When key court dates and deadlines are approaching

We’re available to answer questions, prepare you for hearings, and ensure your voice is heard every step of the way.

Can You Go to Jail for a First-Time Offense in Ohio?

Yes. Even first-time offenders can face jail time in Cleveland Municipal Court or other Northeast Ohio courts, depending on the charge. Common first-time cases we handle include:

• Domestic violence accusations
• OVI (operating a vehicle while impaired)
• Theft and property crimes
• Drug possession

A public defender may urge you to accept a plea quickly to move your case forward. At Patrick M. Farrell Co. L.P.A., we evaluate every angle before advising any plea—because your future deserves more than a rushed decision.

What Happens After a Criminal Arrest in Cleveland?

If you’ve been arrested in Cleveland or surrounding areas, here’s a general timeline of what to expect:

1. Arraignment: Your charges are formally presented. Bail may be set.
2. Discovery: Evidence is exchanged between the prosecution and defense.
3. Pre-Trial Motions: We challenge improper evidence or rights violations.
4. Plea Bargaining or Trial Prep: Based on the facts, we push for dismissal, reduced charges, or prepare for trial.
5. Trial: If no resolution is reached, your case proceeds to trial at Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court or Cleveland Municipal Court.

Each stage is an opportunity to strengthen your defense—but only if your lawyer has the time and skill to act decisively. That’s where private counsel makes all the difference.

Common Defenses Our Criminal Lawyers Use in Cuyahoga County

Our firm has handled thousands of criminal cases. Some of the defense strategies we may explore include:

• Illegal search and seizure (violations of your Fourth Amendment rights)
• Mistaken identity or false accusations
• Violation of Miranda rights
• Lack of intent or insufficient evidence
• Entrapment by law enforcement

We regularly represent clients at the Cleveland Municipal Court, Parma Municipal Court, and courts throughout Cuyahoga County. Our reputation as aggressive, strategic litigators often leads to favorable outcomes long before trial.

Private vs. Public: Why Personalized Defense Matters

When deciding between a public defender and a private criminal defense attorney, understanding the differences can help you make the right choice for your future:

Attorney Selection

• Public Defender: Assigned to you by the court—you don’t get to choose who represents you.
• Private Attorney (Patrick M. Farrell Co. L.P.A.): You select an experienced legal team you trust to defend your case with full commitment.

Caseload

• Public Defender: Often overwhelmed with dozens or even hundreds of active cases at a time.
• Private Attorney: We limit our caseload to ensure each client receives the focus and preparation their case deserves.

Communication

• Public Defender: May have limited time to meet with you or return your calls.
• Private Attorney: We prioritize regular updates, open communication, and accessible guidance throughout your case.

Strategy Customization

• Public Defender: May take a more standardized approach due to limited time or resources.
• Private Attorney: We build a tailored defense strategy based on the specific facts, evidence, and legal options in your case.

Trial Preparation

• Public Defender: May push for plea deals to manage their caseload and avoid trial.
• Private Attorney: Our team prepares thoroughly for trial from the start, using expert witnesses and detailed evidence review when needed.

Your Future Is Worth the Investment

Criminal charges can affect your:

• Employment and licensure
• Immigration status
• Gun rights
• Ability to secure housing or loans

Hiring a private criminal lawyer may feel like a big decision—but it’s also the best way to protect your long-term future, especially when the stakes are high.

Contact a Cleveland Criminal Defense Lawyer Today

If you’ve been arrested in Cleveland, Lakewood, or anywhere in Northeast Ohio, don’t wait. Call or text Patrick M. Farrell Co. L.P.A. at (216) 661-5050 now for a free, confidential consultation with an experienced Cleveland criminal defense lawyer. You can also fill out our secure online form—your information stays confidential, and an attorney from our trusted legal team will follow up shortly. Our trusted criminal defense attorneys defend clients across Cuyahoga County, including Akron, Parma, and Euclid. We build personalized, aggressive strategies to protect your rights, your record, and your future. Let us fight for you—starting today.

‍