Think The Breathalyzer Is Always Right? Here’s How Results Get Challenged

Breath tests are treated as powerful evidence in Ohio OVI cases, but a number on a printout is not automatically the same thing as proof beyond a reasonable doubt. What matters is how the test was administered, whether the instrument was properly maintained, and whether the reading fits the full timeline of the stop. Patrick M. Farrell Co. L.P.A. serves clients in Cleveland, Sandusky, Norwalk, and Willard, and across Cuyahoga County and Northeast Ohio. If you are being investigated or charged, talking with a Cleveland criminal defense attorney early can help you protect your license and challenge shaky evidence before it becomes the foundation of the case.

Why Breathalyzer Evidence Can Decide An Ohio OVI Case

OVI prosecutions often revolve around three categories of evidence: the officer’s observations, roadside testing, and chemical testing. In a widely reported Ohio OVI matter involving a high-profile coach, public attention focused on the stop details, body camera footage, and the decision not to take a breath test, followed later by a reduced outcome in court. That pattern is common in real cases: testing decisions, police procedure, and documentation can drive what happens next.

If you did take a breath test and the result is being used against you, the most important question is not “What did the machine say?” It is “Can the state prove the result is reliable and legally admissible?”

Can You Challenge A Breathalyzer Result In Ohio?

Yes. Breath tests are admissible in many cases, but they are not immune from challenge. In Ohio, effective challenges are usually case-specific and focus on whether the state followed required procedures and whether the result can be trusted in context.

A Cleveland criminal defense lawyer will typically look for problems in four core areas:

• The stop and the reason for the testing
• The observation and testing process
• Instrument maintenance and calibration records
• Consistency between the test result, the timeline, and other evidence

How Breathalyzer Results Get Challenged In Cleveland And Cuyahoga County

Breath testing is technical. That works both ways. It can strengthen the state’s case when everything is done correctly, and it can create weaknesses when steps are missed or records do not support the result.

Observation Period And Mouth Alcohol Problems

Breath testing protocols typically require a period of observation before the test. The point is to reduce the risk that mouth alcohol, regurgitation, or recent substances in the mouth inflate the reading.

Challenges often focus on issues like:

• The officer was distracted or multitasking during observation
• The driver burped, vomited, or had reflux symptoms close to testing
• Tobacco, breath spray, or other substances were present
• The paperwork does not reflect what actually happened on video

Operator Training And Step By Step Procedure

Breath testing requires a trained operator and a consistent process. In many cases, the strongest defense work is simply comparing what the officer wrote to what the video and instrument logs show.

A criminal defense attorney in Cleveland may examine:

• Whether the operator was certified to run the instrument
• Whether the device reported errors, interruptions, or abnormal results
• Whether required steps were skipped or performed out of order
• Whether the officer documented the process accurately

Instrument Maintenance, Calibration, And Record Retention

Breath test instruments are only as reliable as their maintenance history. Defense review often includes calibration checks, service logs, and any reports of problems.

If records are missing, unclear, or inconsistent, that can support:

• A motion to exclude the result
• A challenge to how much weight the jury should give the number
• Negotiation leverage for reduced charges or alternative outcomes

Timing Matters More Than Most People Realize

A breathalyzer result is a snapshot, and the timing of the stop, the arrest, and the test matters. Alcohol absorption can rise or fall depending on when someone last drank, what they ate, and how the body metabolizes alcohol. Prosecutors may present the number as a fixed truth, but the defense will evaluate whether the state’s interpretation matches the timeline.

Medical Conditions And Interfering Factors

Some medical conditions can affect breath testing or create misleading indicators that are later treated as impairment. This is not a blanket defense and it is not relevant in every case, but it can matter in the right situation, especially when symptoms overlap with what officers are trained to look for.

What Happens After An OVI Arrest In Ohio

If you were arrested in Cleveland or elsewhere in Cuyahoga County, your case usually moves through predictable stages. Understanding the process helps you avoid missteps.

Investigation And Charging

Police reports, body camera footage, and testing documentation form the first version of the case. If a breath test was taken, that result often becomes a central exhibit early.

Bond And Conditions

Bond can include conditions related to driving privileges, alcohol use, and reporting requirements. Violations can create new issues and can affect how the court views compliance.

Arraignment

This is where charges are formally entered and a plea is recorded. A Cleveland criminal defense attorney can also address bond and begin pushing for discovery early.

Pretrial And Discovery

This is the evidence phase. The defense reviews the stop, video, test logs, and maintenance records, then identifies what can be challenged.

Motions, Negotiations, And Trial

Motions may target the stop, the arrest, the statements made, or the breath test itself. Negotiations often become more productive after the defense has tested the state’s evidence. If needed, the case can proceed to trial, where the state must prove every element beyond a reasonable doubt.

Common Reasons OVI Cases Escalate

Many people are surprised by how quickly an OVI case becomes serious. Escalation often happens because multiple pieces of evidence get stacked together:

• Statements made during the stop
• Observations described in the report
• Video that appears to confirm impairment
• A breath test number treated as conclusive

A Cleveland drunk driving lawyer focuses on whether those pieces actually align, and whether the state can legally use each one.

What To Do Now If You Failed A Breath Test Or Police Want To Talk

If the breathalyzer result is central to your case, early decisions matter. Practical steps include:

• Do not give an interview without counsel. Polite silence is often safer than trying to explain.
• Do not discuss the case by text, social media message, or email.
• Write down the timeline while it is fresh: where you were, when you drove, when you were stopped, and what occurred before the test.
• Preserve documents and paperwork you received.
• Ask your lawyer about requesting and reviewing maintenance records and test logs early.

If you are searching for a Cleveland criminal defense lawyer because your breath test result is driving the charge, early legal guidance can help identify the most effective challenges and protect your options.

When Breathalyzer Results Should Be Questioned In Ohio

Breathalyzer results can be challenged in Ohio, but the strongest defenses usually focus on the details: observation and testing procedure, instrument maintenance records, the timing of the test, and inconsistencies between reports and video. A Cleveland criminal defense attorney can evaluate whether the state followed the rules and whether the result is reliable enough to support a conviction. Patrick M. Farrell Co. L.P.A. represents people throughout Cleveland, Sandusky, Norwalk, and Willard, and across Cuyahoga County and Northeast Ohio. Call or text 216-661-5050 for a free, confidential consultation.

Text or Call: 216-661-5050 • Contact: Submit a Request • Email: cindy@patfarrelllaw.com

‍