First-Time Shoplifting Offense in Ohio? Here’s What Happens Next

At Patrick M. Farrell Co. L.P.A., we know that being charged with shoplifting can feel overwhelming, embarrassing, and even confusing. You may have acted on impulse, made a poor decision, or simply found yourself in the wrong place at the wrong time. No matter the circumstances, a theft conviction can have long-lasting consequences on your record, career, and future. That’s why we’re here—to protect your rights, minimize damage, and help you move forward with confidence.

Understanding Shoplifting Charges in Ohio

Ohio does not have a separate statute for “shoplifting.” Instead, all such offenses fall under Ohio’s general theft law—Ohio Revised Code § 2913.02—which prohibits knowingly obtaining or exerting control over someone else’s property without consent, through deception, threat, or intimidation.

Common forms of shoplifting include:

• Concealing merchandise and leaving a store without paying
• Switching price tags or packaging to pay less
• Walking out of a store with unpaid items due to distraction or mistake
• Returning stolen items for store credit

Even if the value of the item is low, the charge can have significant consequences if not handled properly. What might seem like a petty mistake can quickly become a major legal issue.

Penalties for Shoplifting in Ohio

The severity of your charge depends primarily on the value of the stolen property and whether you have prior offenses. Penalties can range from a misdemeanor to a felony.

Misdemeanor Theft (Property valued under $1,000)

• Charge: First-degree misdemeanor
• Penalty: Up to 180 days in jail, up to $1,000 in fines
• Collateral Consequences: Probation, community service, restitution, permanent record of theft

Felony Theft

• Fifth-Degree Felony: $1,000–$7,500 stolen
  
  • 6–12 months in prison, up to $2,500 fine
• Fourth-Degree Felony: $7,500–$150,000 stolen
  
  • 6–18 months in prison, up to $5,000 fine
• Third-Degree Felony: $150,000–$750,000 stolen
  
  • 1–5 years in prison, up to $10,000 fine
• Second-Degree Felony: $750,000–$1.5 million
  
  • 2–8 years in prison, up to $15,000 fine
• First-Degree Felony: $1.5 million or more
  
  • 3–11 years in prison, up to $20,000 fine

Additional Penalties

• Civil Recovery: Retailers may sue for the value of goods and damages
• Restitution: Court-ordered repayment to the victim
• Employment Consequences: Difficulty finding or keeping a job
• Immigration Impact: Possible deportation or visa denial
• Professional Licensing Issues: Revocation or denial of licenses in healthcare, finance, law, etc.

Your Legal Options and the Criminal Process

What to Expect in a Shoplifting Case

1. Arrest or Summons – You may be detained by store security and later charged.
2. Arraignment – Your first court appearance; you’ll enter a plea and bail may be set.
3. Discovery and Pretrial – Your attorney reviews the evidence and files legal motions.
4. Negotiation or Trial – Many cases are resolved through plea deals, diversion, or dismissal.
5. Sentencing or Dismissal – If convicted, the court will impose penalties; if successful, the case may be sealed or expunged later.

Diversion and Expungement

In some counties, including Cuyahoga County, you may be eligible for a pretrial diversion program if this is your first offense. Successful completion can result in dismissal of charges and eligibility for expungement (sealing your record).

Defense Strategies for Shoplifting Charges

At Patrick M. Farrell Co. L.P.A., our Cleveland criminal defense attorneys thoroughly investigate every case. Depending on your situation, we may use strategies such as:

• Lack of Intent: You forgot to pay or made an honest mistake
• Mistaken Identity: You were misidentified by store staff or surveillance
• Unlawful Detention: Your rights were violated by store personnel or police
• Illegal Search and Seizure: Evidence was obtained improperly
• Diversion Advocacy: We help eligible clients pursue programs that dismiss charges

We aim to protect your future, reduce or dismiss charges, and avoid convictions whenever possible.

Why You Need a Cleveland Shoplifting Lawyer

A conviction—even for petty theft—can have lifelong consequences. Don’t assume that just because this is “minor,” you don’t need legal help. We know the courts, we know Ohio law, and we know how to fight for the best possible outcome.

When you work with our firm, we:

• Conduct a full case review and evidence analysis
• Handle all court filings, negotiations, and appearances
• Explore options for dismissal, reduction, or diversion
• Build strong legal defenses and protect your rights at trial if needed

We’ve represented clients in Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, and throughout Northeast Ohio, including college students, professionals, and first-time offenders.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Shoplifting Charges in Ohio

Is shoplifting a felony or misdemeanor in Ohio?

It depends on the value of the items taken. If the total is under $1,000, it’s usually a first-degree misdemeanor. Over $1,000 and it becomes a felony.

Can I go to jail for a first offense?

Yes, but many first-time offenders are eligible for diversion programs that can help avoid jail time and keep their records clean.

Will a shoplifting conviction stay on my record?

Yes, unless you take steps to have the record sealed. Misdemeanor theft may be eligible for expungement after a waiting period. Felonies involving theft may not qualify.

Can I be sued by the store?

Yes. In addition to criminal penalties, the store may pursue a civil recovery for damages, loss prevention costs, and even legal fees.

What is a diversion program, and am I eligible?

Diversion programs are alternatives to prosecution for first-time or low-level offenders. If completed successfully, your charges may be dismissed. Eligibility depends on the court, your record, and the facts of your case.

Can I be charged if I never left the store?

Yes. In Ohio, intent to deprive the store of property—even without leaving the premises—can lead to charges. Hiding items or altering price tags may be enough to warrant arrest.

How will a shoplifting charge affect my job or background check?

A theft-related conviction can appear on background checks and may negatively impact employment, professional licenses, housing, and educational opportunities.

Do I have to appear in court if I’m charged with shoplifting?

Yes. Failure to appear can result in additional charges and a bench warrant. An attorney can help manage court dates and, in some cases, appear on your behalf.

What if I was mistakenly accused of shoplifting?

Mistaken identity, faulty video footage, or misunderstanding can lead to false accusations. A defense attorney can investigate and challenge the evidence used against you.

Can I be charged for switching price tags?

Yes. Altering or switching tags to pay less is considered theft and is charged similarly to shoplifting under Ohio law.

What should I do if I’ve been caught shoplifting in Cleveland?

Contact a criminal defense attorney immediately. Do not speak to police or store security without representation. Early intervention gives you the best chance of a favorable outcome.

Take Action Today with Patrick M. Farrell Co. L.P.A.

Whether you’re facing a misdemeanor theft charge or a serious felony shoplifting accusation, don’t navigate the Ohio criminal justice system alone. At Patrick M. Farrell Co. L.P.A., we provide trusted, aggressive, and experienced defense to protect your freedom, your record, and your reputation.

Call or text (216) 661-5050 now for a free, confidential consultation with an experienced Cleveland criminal defense defense lawyer. You can also fill out our secure online form—your information stays confidential, and an attorney from our trusted legal team will follow up shortly. We don’t just take cases—we defend futures.

‍