Fraud Charges in Ohio Explained: Penalties, Defenses & What to Do Next

In Ohio, fraud is classified as a white-collar crime—and the penalties, including prison time and permanent criminal records, can be just as severe as those tied to violent offenses. At Patrick M. Farrell Co. L.P.A., we represent individuals across Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, and Northeast Ohio, who are accused of white-collar crimes like fraud. We help clients understand their charges, assert their rights, and build strong legal defenses to protect their future.

What Is Considered Fraud in Ohio?

Fraud involves intentionally deceiving someone for financial gain. Under Ohio Revised Code § 2913.01, fraud includes any act that knowingly:

• Misrepresents or withholds key information
• Prevents someone from learning the truth
• Creates a false impression about facts, finances, or legal obligations

If that deception leads someone to hand over money, services, or benefits, you could be charged with a criminal offense—often linked to theft.

Important: Even unintentional mistakes can appear deceptive to investigators. If you've been contacted by law enforcement or accused of fraud, contact our criminal defense attorneys immediately before making any statements.

6 Common Types of Fraud Charges in Northeast Ohio

Our Cleveland federal criminal defense attorneys defend clients facing many types of fraud charges, including:

1. Investment Fraud

Schemes like Ponzi schemes, pump-and-dump stock manipulation, or falsifying returns to attract investors all fall under this category. Investment fraud charges often involve state and federal investigations and can result in serious penalties.

2. Mortgage Fraud

Includes misrepresenting income, employment, or assets on a mortgage application—or financing a property that doesn’t exist. These cases often involve significant financial institutions and carry serious penalties.

3. Insurance Fraud

Ranging from exaggerated personal injury claims to falsified damage reports, insurance fraud may also include medical billing fraud by healthcare providers.

4. Credit Card and Bank Fraud

Includes using stolen card information, falsifying applications, or forging checks. These charges can escalate quickly if multiple accounts or high-value transactions are involved.

5. Government Program Fraud

Lying on Medicaid, Workers’ Compensation, or unemployment applications, or falsifying documents to receive public assistance can lead to prosecution for fraud.

6. Utility or Telecommunications Fraud

This includes setting up services under a fake identity or tampering with cable, internet, or phone lines. These offenses are often investigated aggressively by utility companies and prosecutors.

Penalties for Fraud in Ohio

Fraud charges in Ohio vary based on the amount of financial loss and the type of victim (e.g., a bank, government agency, or vulnerable person).

• Misdemeanor Fraud (under $1,000): May result in up to 6 months in jail and $1,000 in fines.
• Felony Fraud (over $1,000): Can lead to prison time ranging from 6 months to 11 years, with fines up to $20,000.
• Aggravating Factors (elderly victims, public agency fraud, or organized schemes): Often increase the severity of penalties.

You may also be ordered to pay full restitution with interest—and a conviction will leave a permanent mark on your criminal record.

Can You Go to Jail for a First-Time Fraud Offense?

Yes. Even if this is your first criminal charge, Ohio courts take fraud seriously. If the case involves more than $1,000 or a government entity, you could face felony charges and potential prison time.

However, at Patrick M. Farrell Co. L.P.A., we fight to protect your future. For first-time offenders, we may be able to:

• Negotiate reduced or dismissed charges
• Pursue diversion programs
• Avoid incarceration through probation
• Challenge evidence gathered in violation of your rights

10 Defenses Against Fraud Charges in Ohio

1. Lack of Intent to Defraud

Fraud requires knowingly or intentionally misleading another person or entity. If the prosecution can’t prove you had the specific intent to deceive—such as in cases of miscommunication, clerical error, or misunderstanding—you may avoid conviction.

2. Insufficient or Unreliable Evidence

Many fraud cases rely heavily on paper trails, emails, or financial transactions. If the evidence is incomplete, circumstantial, or doesn’t directly tie you to the alleged scheme, we can argue that the state has not met its burden of proof.

3. Mistake of Fact

If you believed the information you provided was accurate at the time (e.g., you thought an income source was valid or that you qualified for a government benefit), this can be a strong defense against knowingly fraudulent conduct.

4. Coerced or Involuntary Statements

If you were questioned by investigators without your rights being read, or if your statement was coerced or obtained through threats, we may be able to suppress those statements and weaken the state’s case.

5. Violation of Constitutional Rights

If law enforcement obtained financial documents, digital data, or communications through illegal searches, wiretaps, or subpoenas, we can challenge the admissibility of that evidence under the Fourth Amendment.

6. Lack of Personal Involvement or Knowledge

In complex fraud schemes involving multiple people or departments, it’s possible to be wrongly accused due to proximity. We may show that you weren’t involved in decision-making or lacked control over the documents or information at issue.

7. Duress or Coercion

If you were pressured, threatened, or manipulated into participating in a fraudulent act—especially by a supervisor, partner, or family member—we may raise a defense of duress to explain your actions and avoid criminal liability.

8. Entrapment by Law Enforcement

If investigators or undercover agents encouraged or facilitated the crime and you wouldn’t have committed it otherwise, entrapment could be a viable defense—particularly in wire fraud or online fraud stings.

9. Plea to a Lesser Offense or Diversion Program

In cases involving first-time offenders or small financial amounts, we may negotiate a reduction in charges to a non-fraud-related offense (like a misdemeanor theft or disorderly conduct) or secure participation in a diversion program to avoid jail time and a criminal record.

10. False Allegations or Revenge Motives

If someone reported you out of anger, retaliation, or misunderstanding—such as a former business partner, client, or ex-spouse—we can expose inconsistencies in their claims and build a defense around personal motive.

What Happens After a Fraud Arrest in Cleveland?

Here’s what to expect after being charged:

1. Booking and Processing – Fingerprints, mugshots, and a background check.
2. Arraignment – You’ll hear the charges, enter a plea, and potentially be assigned bail.
3. Pretrial Hearings and Discovery – This stage involves evidence exchange, legal motions, and strategy building by our criminal defense team.
4. Plea Negotiation or Trial – Depending on your goals and the facts of your case, we’ll guide you toward the best possible outcome.

Never speak to law enforcement or prosecutors without a lawyer. Even casual remarks can be twisted into damaging admissions.

Don’t Wait. Your Freedom and Reputation Are on the Line.

If you're facing fraud allegations, every moment counts. Early mistakes—like talking to investigators or signing paperwork—can make your case harder to fight. Let our trusted federal criminal defense attorneys protect your rights and work toward the best possible outcome. Call or text Patrick M. Farrell Co. L.P.A. at (216) 661-5050 now for a free, confidential consultation with an experienced Cleveland criminal defense lawyer. You can also fill out our secure online form—your information stays confidential, and an attorney from our trusted legal team will follow up shortly. 

‍